Various States All Pile On To Push Blatantly Unconstitutional Laws That Say Social Media Can't Moderate

Various States All Pile On To Push Blatantly Unconstitutional Laws That Say Social Media Can't Moderate

3 years ago
Anonymous $K6XgmDN5_o

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20210203/16453346175/various-states-all-pile-to-push-blatantly-unconstitutional-laws-that-say-social-media-cant-moderate.shtml

A bunch of Republican state legislators across the country are apparently unconcerned with either the 1st Amendment (or reality) have decided that they need to stop social media companies from engaging in any sort of content moderation. Earlier this week, Florida Man Governor Ron DeSantis proposed just such a law, which would be struck down as unconstitutional with amazing speed. The bill, dubbed the "Transparency in Technology Act" would do a bunch of things laid out in this infographic the Florida GOP sent around, almost all of which the state has no authority to do. On the content moderation front, it would require set standards for content moderation that can't easily be changed and require the company apply those standards consistently.

That's what lots of people ask for without realizing that's an impossible ask. "Consistency" is not nearly as clear as people seem to think it is. Every scenario is different, and context plays a huge role in determining these things -- but people who complain about inconsistent enforcement never seem to recognize the wider context, and always focus in on some superficial similarity about the content, and insist that different outcomes mean inconsistency. It also ignores the scale of the problem. It also fails to take into account that policies have to keep being updated, because the issues that trust and safety teams face constantly are changing.

Last Seen
3 hours ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000
Last Seen
8 minutes ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000
Last Seen
41 minutes ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000
Last Seen
about an hour ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000
Last Seen
14 minutes ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000
Last Seen
7 hours ago
Reputation
0
Spam
0.000