https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200902/18254645239/ninth-circuit-says-nsas-bulk-phone-records-collection-was-illegal-most-likely-unconstitutional.shtml

The NSA's bulk phone records collection is dead. It died of exposure. And reform. It was Ed Snowden's first leak back in 2013. A few years later, a reform bill prompted by Snowden's leaks revamped the program, forcing the NSA to tailor its requests for phone records from telcos. The NSA used to collect everything and sort through at its leisure. But once the program eliminated the "bulk" from the NSA's bulk collection, the NSA couldn't figure out how to obtain records without getting more than it was legally allowed to take.

This recent courtroom win may have come a bit too late to matter much. But it's still a big win. In a case involving material support for terrorists by Somali citizens living in the United States, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has arrived at the conclusion that the NSA's bulk phone records collection is/was illegal.