576 German Artists Want EU Copyright Directive Made Worse, With No Exceptions For Memes Or Mashups

576 German Artists Want EU Copyright Directive Made Worse, With No Exceptions For Memes Or Mashups

3 years ago
Anonymous $RGO3jP_V_c

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201202/03473145807/576-german-artists-want-eu-copyright-directive-made-worse-with-no-exceptions-memes-mashups.shtml

When the EU Copyright Directive was being drawn up, one of the main battlegrounds concerned memes. The fear was that the upload filters brought in by the new law would not be able to distinguish between legal use of copyright material for things like memes, quotation, criticism, review, caricature, parody and pastiche, and illegal infringements. Supporters of the Directive insisted that memes and such-like would be allowed, and that it was simply scaremongering to suggest otherwise. When the Directive was passed, BBC News even ran a story with the headline "Memes exempt as EU backs controversial copyright law". The MEP Mary Honeyball is quoted as saying: "There's no problem with memes at all. This directive was never intended to stop memes and mashups."

But just as supporters insisted that upload filters would not be obligatory -- and then afterwards changed their story, admitting they were the only way to implement the new law -- so people who insisted that memes and parodies would still be allowed are now demanding that they should be banned. Copyright companies were the first to make that shift, and now a group of 576 German artists have sent a letter to the German government and politicians complaining about the proposed implementation of the Copyright Directive in their country (original in German). In particular, they are appalled by: